A crucial part of IPA's mission is to inform member associations and the wider global publishing community about breaking developments which will impact publishers. We do this through a number of channels. the IPA website, our monthly e-newsletter, press releases and the IPA's dedicated social media feeds.

In Kirtsaeng v. John Wiley & Sons, Inc, the US Supreme Court decided on 19 March 2013 that the "first sale" doctrine applies to copies of a copyrighted work lawfully made abroad. Consequently, an American publisher in the future may be unable to prevent the unauthorized importation into the United States of low cost editions of its textbooks produced for developing markets.

IPA considers that this decision threatens low cost textbooks, which are critically important to students in developing countries.

Commenting on the US Supreme Court ruling in Kirtsaeng v John Wiley & Sons Inc, the IPA’s Secretary General Jens Bammel said: “Allowing the domestic importation of lowcost editions of textbooks from developing markets is a direct threat to low-cost editions themselves. Students in developing countries will, literally, pay the price for this decision. One of the best developments for students in recent years is differential pricing: the ability for publishers to set their prices to market and thus put many international textbooks within reach of students in poorer countries. It is unfortunate that these exciting new business models are now being threatened by such a decision”.

Jens Bammel added: “We are heartened that not all judges chose to ignore how global publishers reach and support education in poor countries. As Justice Ginsburg noted in her dissenting opinion: “Because economic conditions and demand for particular goods vary across the globe, copyright owners have a financial incentive to charge different prices for copies their works in different geographic regions. Their ability to engage in such price discrimination, however, is undermined if arbitrageurs are permitted to import copies from low-price regions and sell them in high-price regions”. In the longer term, we hope that this view will prevail”.

More about the Case

In order to finance his studies in the United States, a Thai national, Kirtsaeng, resold in the US textbooks purchased by his family in Thai bookshops and manufactured by Wiley’s Asian subsidiary. Overall, Kirtsaeng sold several hundred thousand dollars’ worth of textbooks imported in this way, and made a net profit in the range of USD 100,000. When Wiley found out about his activities, Kirtsaeng was sued for copyright infringement. Wiley alleged that Kirtsaeng violated § 602(a)(1) of the US Copyright Act, which prohibits the importation of foreign-made works or goods without the copyright owner's authority. Kirtsaeng claimed that, according to the first-sale doctrine codified in § 109(a), he was permitted to resell Wiley’s textbooks in the United States without Wiley’s permission because the doctrine states that a copyright owner loses exclusive rights after the first sale of the work. Until the Supreme Court ruling, lower US courts had found Kirtsaeng guilty and imposed statutory damages of USD 600,000.

Submit to FacebookSubmit to TwitterSubmit to LinkedIn


Michiel Kolman
20 May 2020
Publishing industry
Educational Publishing
Diversity and Inclusion
Diversity & Inclusion in the publishing industry is not only relevant for the workforce in our industry (see my previous blog on key surveys measuring exactly that), but also for what we publish. Important questions that arise are ...
Michiel Kolman
24 April 2020
Publishing industry
Diversity and Inclusion
It has been impressive to see how fast our industry has responded to the challenges presented by COVID-19. While many publishers are busy trying to keep their businesses running, it would be easy to dismiss diversity and inclusion (D&I) as just a...
Ben Steward
23 April 2020
Publishing industry
Two weeks into the COVID-19 (née coronavirus) pandemic and its attendant doldrums, I noticed some A-list singers were performing via Instagram from the discomfort of their homes. Chris Martin and John Legend were among the first to sign up to the&nbs...
Michiel Kolman
31 March 2020
Publishing industry
Diversity and Inclusion

Close scrutiny showed a more complex but also more positive answer for both the UK and US.

Michiel Kolman
30 January 2020
Publishing industry
Diversity and Inclusion
As we start a new decade, the subject of diversity remains firmly on the radar for most businesses and industries in 2020. This is also true for our own publishing industry as we continue to see how issues around diversity and inclusion, such as wome...
Michiel Kolman
18 December 2019
Publishing industry
Diversity and Inclusion

IPA D&I envoy, Michiel Kolman interviews Elsevier’s Simon Holt and Springer Nature’s Kirsty Bone about their experiences of having a disability and working in the publishing industry. This is a long but fascinating read.

Hugo Setzer
07 November 2019
Publishing industry

October and the first days of November were again very busy, with visits to four different countries and three book fairs in the course of three weeks.

James Taylor
25 October 2019
Publishing industry

SCCR 39 concluded this evening with an agreement found on how to keep the Exceptions and Limitations discussion moving forward and the other agenda items wrapped up and a possible new issue raised in the chamber.

Press Releases campaign 2020


Press Releases campaign 2019


Press Releases campaign 2018


Newsletters campaigns 2020


Newsletters campaigns 2019


Newsletters campaigns 2018


International Publishers Association

23, avenue de France
1202 Geneva, Switzerland
+41 22 704 18 20

Subscribe to our newsletter